In a development that has stunned much of the rugby world, Scott Robertson has departed his role as head coach of the All Blacks just two years into a four-year appointment. The announcement, made shortly after New Zealand Rugby completed its end-of-season review, marks a dramatic shift in direction as the nation prepares for the 2027 Rugby World Cup.
Robertson, 51, took charge after the 2023 World Cup with enormous expectations. His tenure with the Crusaders, where he delivered seven consecutive Super Rugby titles, had established him as one of the most successful club coaches of the modern era. Many believed he was the ideal candidate to steer New Zealand back to the top of world rugby.
During his time in charge of the All Blacks, Robertson oversaw 20 wins from 27 Tests, a strong record on paper. Yet his spell was marked by inconsistency and a handful of historic or heavy defeats, including the team’s first ever away loss to Argentina and a significant defeat to England at Twickenham. These results, combined with fluctuating performances, fuelled growing pressure and scrutiny.
New Zealand Rugby chair David Kirk stated that the organisation felt the timing was right to reassess its direction heading into the second half of the World Cup cycle. While the decision was framed as a mutual agreement, it is clear that the review raised concerns about the team’s trajectory, both on and off the field. The search for a new coach is already underway, with several experienced figures being considered.
Robertson spoke emotionally about his departure, saying he was “gutted” but proud of the work he and his staff had done. He highlighted the development of young players and the effort put into rebuilding depth across key positions. Despite the abrupt end, he described coaching the All Blacks as the honour of his life.
Reaction across New Zealand has been mixed. Supporters in Canterbury, where Robertson became a coaching icon, expressed shock and frustration, believing he had not been given enough time to fully implement his vision. Others have argued that the team’s inconsistency justified a change and that the All Blacks need renewed clarity and stability as they head toward 2027.
Online discussions have reflected this division, with some fans criticising what they see as impatience from New Zealand Rugby, while others point to tactical issues, muddled game planning, and the need for a stronger on-field identity. The debate highlights a broader concern about how New Zealand rugby adapts to an increasingly competitive global landscape.
Attention now turns to the next chapter. The new head coach will inherit a squad with significant talent but also significant expectations. With major test series on the horizon and the World Cup cycle accelerating, the pressure to restore the All Blacks’ aura will be immense.
Scott Robertson’s departure marks one of the most consequential coaching changes in modern All Blacks history. It underscores both the intensity of the role and the high standards expected of anyone who leads the most storied team in rugby. Whether this decision ultimately propels New Zealand forward or proves to be a misstep will unfold in the months and years ahead.
